Actor Kiefer Sutherland is formally denying wrongdoing in a lawsuit brought by an Uber driver who accuses him of assault, arguing in new court papers that any force he used was in self-defense.
In documents filed Nov. 10 in Los Angeles Superior Court, attorneys for the “24” star responded to an amended complaint from Rafael Manvelyan. The filing denies “each and every allegation” and claims Sutherland “reasonably believed” he faced an imminent threat during the encounter.
“Plaintiff’s claims are barred, in whole or in part, because Defendant’s alleged actions, if any, were undertaken in the reasonable belief that Plaintiff posed an imminent threat of bodily harm to Defendant and/or others,” the filing states. “Defendant acted reasonably and used only such force as was reasonably necessary under the circumstances.”
The filing does not specify what actions by Manvelyan allegedly prompted that belief.
Background on the Jan. 12 arrest
The lawsuit stems from an alleged altercation near Sunset Boulevard and Fairfax Avenue in Los Angeles. Sutherland, 59, was arrested Jan. 12 and released the same day on $50,000 bond, according to arrest records.
Manvelyan’s amended complaint alleges Sutherland appeared intoxicated, threatened him and attacked him during the ride, including placing him in a chokehold and striking him repeatedly. He is seeking damages for physical injuries, emotional distress, lost earnings and medical expenses.
Dispatch audio obtained previously described an alleged chase involving a suspect believed to be Sutherland. The initial call came in around 12:15 a.m., with a later update indicating the suspect had stopped pursuing the person who reported the incident. “Suspect is no longer chasing the PR, now is behind PR’s vehicle, a black SUV. No further,” a voice on the recording said.
The Los Angeles Police Department said at the time that officers responded to a report of an assault involving a rideshare driver. “The investigation determined that the suspect, later identified as Kiefer Sutherland, entered a rideshare vehicle, physically assaulted the driver (the victim), and made criminal threats toward the victim,” police said.
Suit called ‘frivolous’
Sutherland’s attorneys went further than a simple denial, arguing the lawsuit itself amounts to harassment. “This suit is being pursued in bad faith for vexatious reasons for the purpose of harassing Defendant,” the filing states, describing the claims as “frivolous and groundless.”
The defense also disputed Manvelyan’s claims of emotional distress, suggesting any such harm could come from unrelated causes. “Plaintiff’s claims for emotional distress injuries and damages are barred, in whole or in part, to the extent that such damages are attributable to preexisting or concurrent psychological conditions, unrelated stressors or other independent causes, rather than any act or omission of Defendant,” the attorneys wrote. The filing does not include medical records or identify any specific diagnosis.
Sutherland is asking the court to dismiss the amended complaint with prejudice, seeking attorneys’ fees and court costs, and has requested a jury trial.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login