A federal judge has refused to throw out part of President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, allowing four counts tied to seven specific accusations of criminal conduct to move forward while dismissing the bulk of the case.
U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday’s ruling, issued Thursday, centers on claims that the Times and its publisher, Penguin Random House, acted with reckless disregard for the truth in “Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success,” a book written by Times journalists Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner.
Merryday found that the book’s authors and publisher made definitive claims of complex tax fraud and money laundering against Trump and his father without obtaining a formal legal opinion or conducting forensic auditing, and without any charges or convictions ever having been brought.
“In other words, the facts alleged in the complaint create at least a plausible inference that the authors and the publishers knew that no reliable conclusion about violations of the tax laws, including especially the estate and gift tax laws, is possible without reliance on qualified opinion formulated after the necessary factual and legal research and analysis, which they knowingly failed to obtain,” Merryday wrote.
The judge also rejected the Times’ defense that it had relied on outside commentators, including a former prosecutor who said a Trump transaction “smells like a crime” and a professor who called it “suspicious.” Merryday wrote that such characterizations fall well short of a formal legal opinion capable of removing serious doubt about the truthfulness of accusations of fraud or tax evasion.
A spokesman for Trump’s legal team said the ruling marks a win for the president’s long-running fight with the paper.
“President Trump continues holding the Fake News accountable for deceiving the American people. Judge Merryday has correctly denied the motion to dismiss filed by The New York Times, Penguin Publishing, and their writers, as to President Trump’s powerhouse defamation lawsuit,” the spokesman said, adding that “these Defendants will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump.”
The victory for Trump’s side is partial. Merryday dismissed two full counts, threw out 27 other challenged statements as protected speech under the First Amendment standard set by New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, and denied Trump’s request to amend his complaint for a third time.
A New York Times spokesperson said the paper was encouraged by the overall outcome.
“The Times is encouraged to see Judge Merryday’s dismissal of almost all claims against us. We continue to believe the remaining claim in the filing has no legal merit. We look forward to making this argument as we continue to defend ourselves against this baseless attack on The Times and the rights of the free and independent press in this country,” the spokesperson said.
Merryday has ordered The New York Times to file a formal answer to the surviving claims within 28 days.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login