Circuit Court Judge David Carpenter, a Democrat whose past rulings have drawn criticism after people he released went on to commit further violent crimes, is now speaking out against a state law that lets Alabama judges deny bail to defendants facing certain violent charges.
Carpenter called Aniah’s Law a “direct assault” on the constitutional presumption of innocence, arguing that people should not be held in jail indefinitely based only on a criminal charge, before any conviction.
In a social media post, Carpenter drew a comparison between public reaction to license plate reading cameras, such as Flock cameras, and the broader public’s response to expanding pretrial detention laws.
“Can someone explain to me why the people who are so alarmed that a flock camera might spot their car on a public road, and they call that government overreach, are silent on the fact that voters across the country keep overwhelmingly passing new laws to empower the government to hold you in jail indefinitely on the basis of a charge only,” Carpenter wrote.
“These laws, like Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, are a direct assault on the Constitutional guarantee of the presumption of innocence. But no one is talking about this at all, much less expressing the hysteria associated with having a camera see a license plate,” he said.
Aniah’s Law was first passed in Alabama in 2022, but voters approved a constitutional amendment this year that expanded the list of offenses it covers. The expansion now includes attempted murder, solicitation or conspiracy to commit murder, and discharging a firearm or explosives into an occupied dwelling, building or vehicle.
“We are all one accusation away from being a criminal defendant,” Carpenter wrote in a separate Facebook post.
A Record Under Scrutiny
Carpenter’s comments come as his judicial record faces renewed attention. Local outlet 1819 News has reported that Carpenter once described himself online as a “far left, liberal, progressive, democratic socialist.”
In April 2023, Carpenter approved a plea deal for Damien McDaniel, who had been arrested in 2019 at age 17 for shooting two people in a car, according to 1819 News. After his release, McDaniel allegedly carried out a 14-month shooting spree across Alabama, killing 18 people and injuring more than 30 others.
Carpenter also granted bond to Raukeem Cunningham in a case tied to the 2022 shooting death of a teenage girl. While out on that bond, Cunningham was arrested and charged with fatally shooting three people at a Bessemer gas station in 2024, which led to his original bond being revoked.
Separately, Carpenter reportedly dismissed a 2015 rape charge against Fredrick Terrenda Hampton in 2019. Two days after that dismissal, Hampton met Paighton Houston, who later disappeared; her body was later found buried behind a home after she died of an accidental overdose. Hampton pleaded guilty to abuse of a corpse in connection with Houston’s death, and Carpenter sentenced him to a 20-year split sentence requiring only three years in custody, according to 1819 News.
Houston’s mother has since asked Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall to investigate Carpenter’s decision to release Hampton, whom critics have described as a repeat sex offender.
During his campaign for judicial office, Carpenter said reforming Alabama’s criminal justice system was a top priority. “If elected, I will work to reduce the number of repeat offenders while addressing the expensive problem of prison overcrowding in Alabama,” he said at the time.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login