A federal judge has permanently barred California from enforcing state laws that sought to regulate how federal immigration agents operate within the state, including rules on face coverings and identification.
The laws at issue prohibited Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents from covering their faces while carrying out law enforcement duties and required them to wear visible identification showing their names and badge numbers. Supporters of the measures said the rules were needed after ICE agents had been harassed and threatened at their homes, while backers of the legislation argued masked, unidentified agents undermined public trust and accountability.
The mask provision was authored by state Sen. Scott Wiener, who is also congressman-elect, and was signed into law last year as part of what was called the No Secret Police Act (SB 627). At the time, Wiener described the bill’s passage as “huge news,” saying it would “help stop the masked secret police who are kidnapping people in our communities.”
U.S. District Court Judge Christina Snyder, a senior-status judge appointed by President Bill Clinton, issued the permanent injunction, which broadly forbids state and local officials from enforcing the masking and identification laws against federal agents. The ruling followed an earlier decision with similar reasoning from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit.
The order rests on the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause, which establishes federal law as “the supreme Law of the Land,” and on Article I, which gives Congress authority over immigration and naturalization.
State and federal reactions
California Attorney General Rob Bonta had earlier this year touted a temporary court victory that appeared to uphold the state laws, writing that the Trump administration had “stepped well outside the boundaries of normal law enforcement practice, deploying masked and unidentified agents to carry out immigration enforcement.” That earlier ruling was later reversed. Bonta’s office has not commented publicly since the permanent injunction was issued.
The Department of Justice welcomed the ruling. Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward, Jr. said the injunction “confirms a basic constitutional principle: states do not have the authority to regulate the Federal Government or dictate how federal law enforcement officers perform their official duties.”
“The Constitution does not permit states to interfere with federal operations or place federal officers and their families at risk,” Woodward said. “This injunction ensures that federal law enforcement officers can continue carrying out their important missions without unlawful state interference.”
California is among eight states that have passed laws seeking to restrict federal agents from wearing face masks while on duty. Those laws now face similar legal vulnerability following the ruling.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login