Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration is expected to release a revised plan this week for closing Rikers Island, as city officials privately acknowledge that the jail complex cannot shut down by the legally mandated date of Aug. 31 next year.
The 2019 law requiring Rikers to close set that deadline on the assumption that four new borough-based jails would be ready to take its place. None of those facilities will be completed by then, and all four projects remain behind schedule amid continued community opposition in the boroughs where they are planned.
Even if all four jails are eventually finished, they would provide only about 4,100 beds combined. Rikers currently holds roughly 6,650 people, meaning the city would be barred under state law from closing the island jail even after the new facilities open, since it could not house everyone currently detained there.
As part of the new plan, the mayor is expected to highlight the planned 2026 demolition of Rikers’ North Infirmary Command, a decision first announced in June, as evidence of his commitment to eventually closing the full complex.
Talks with prosecutors
Since summer, Mamdani’s team has been meeting with district attorneys to discuss ways to reduce the jail population, including reevaluating bail decisions, expanding diversion programs and increasing reentry support for people leaving custody. The city’s jail population has been slowly rising rather than falling.
Critics of the closure effort, including the editorial board of the New York Post, have argued that reducing the Rikers population through these measures is unrealistic given who is currently held there. The Post’s opinion piece contends that Rikers primarily houses people facing serious charges, including murder, rape and armed robbery, along with members of gangs such as the Trinitarios and Tren de Aragua, rather than people jailed for low-level, nonviolent offenses.
Some City Council progressives have pushed back against any acknowledgment that the original 2026 deadline is unworkable, with some favoring a full release of the jail population by the original date rather than an extension.
The administration’s forthcoming plan is expected to be released Friday, though the mayor’s office has not detailed how it will reconcile the legal deadline with the construction delays facing the four replacement jails.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login