The American Civil Liberties Union of Washington is suing to block Initiative 638, a measure approved by state voters on Nov. 4 that restricts girls’ and women’s school sports to athletes designated female at birth. The ACLU has said it will ask a state court to overturn the initiative, which passed by more than 10 percentage points.
The Washington state Attorney General’s Office has indicated it will defend the ballot measure in court despite the ACLU’s challenge.
Alliance Defending Freedom, a legal advocacy organization, has filed a motion to intervene in the ACLU’s lawsuit on behalf of Female Athletes United, a coalition of female athletes. A member of that coalition has filed a declaration in the case and wrote in an opinion piece for Fox News describing her own experience competing against a transgender athlete in high school track.
In the op-ed, the athlete said she competed on a girls’ 4×400-meter relay team against a transgender athlete who had previously run in the boys’ category, and that the athlete went on to win the state championship in the girls’ 400-meter race two years in a row. She also filed a complaint last year with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights asking it to investigate the state’s athletic policies and require that sex-designated sports categories be based on sex.
Part of a Broader Trend
Washington was one of four states where voters took up the issue of transgender athletes in women’s sports during this month’s midterm elections. Voters in Arizona, Colorado and Nebraska also passed similar measures, according to the op-ed. Washington’s Initiative 638 passed with support from voters across party lines.
Twenty-seven states have now passed legislation restricting transgender athletes from competing in women’s sports categories, following last summer’s U.S. Supreme Court ruling in State of West Virginia v. B.P.J., which held that states have the authority to regulate the issue.
That case arose after a transgender athlete in West Virginia defeated more than 470 girls over 1,400 times in a single sport, according to the op-ed.
Safety and Fairness Concerns Cited
The op-ed also referenced the case of Washington athlete Kallie Keeler, who it said suffered harm during a high school wrestling match against a competitor who was later revealed to be male, without coaches or officials informing her beforehand.
It cited a United Nations report documenting more than 600 female athletes across 29 sports who have been displaced from events, titles, or opportunities by transgender competitors, who collectively won more than 890 medals in those instances.
The legal fight in Washington now centers on whether the ACLU can succeed in having a court set aside a measure approved directly by voters, with the state’s Attorney General’s Office signaling it intends to uphold the initiative.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login