TV Tribute Reopens Questions About Johnson County Death Investigation
TV Tribute Reopens Questions About Johnson County Death Investigation

Local News

TV Tribute Reopens Questions About Johnson County Death Investigation

Nearly two years after Cole Brings Plenty’s body was found in a Johnson County wooded area, his uncle Mo Brings Plenty says the case remains unresolved, even as a new TV episode draws on the family’s grief.

A television tribute to a young actor whose body was found in a Johnson County wooded area in 2024 has renewed attention on how local authorities handled the case.

Cole Brings Plenty, 27, appeared in Yellowstone spin-off 1923 as well as The Tall Tales of Jim Bridger and Into the Wild Frontier. In April 2024, days after his family reported him missing following an alleged domestic violence incident, his body was discovered in a wooded area here in Johnson County.

The Johnson County Sheriff’s Office said in a press release at the time that there was “no indication of foul play” in his death. That conclusion drew criticism from the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe, which called for “a full and thorough investigation into Cole’s disappearance and subsequent death.”

Nearly two years later, Cole’s uncle, Mo Brings Plenty, says the family has not let the matter rest. Mo Brings Plenty, who works as an actor and as the American Indian Affairs Consultant on the Yellowstone spin-off Marshals, told The Hollywood Reporter in March 2026 that the case still has not been properly investigated.

“He was my nephew, but he was like a son to me. And for his murder to go uninvestigated, and for it to be written off as ‘no foul play,’ because they didn’t want to invest anything into it? It’s heartbreaking. Because we’re taxpaying people as well. So for them to not work for us, no different than how they work for anyone else is, is pretty sad.”

Asked what the family is doing to pursue justice, Mo Brings Plenty said they continue to press the issue publicly.

“Just spread the message. We’ve been in talks with several different people. We’re not letting it go. It was a hard loss for us because this was an individual who was speaking our language, singing our songs and carrying on our traditions. He was the future for us. We want more and more of our young people to be inspired to pick up who we are from a cultural perspective.”

A Storyline Drawn From Real Loss

The case has now reached a national television audience. Marshals Season 2, Episode 6, titled “Roughstock,” centers on a storyline in which Kayce, played by Luke Grimes, helps Mo Brings Plenty’s character search for a missing nephew, Troy, played by Will Strongheart. On screen, Troy disappears while hiking; off screen, the storyline was built directly from the Brings Plenty family’s own experience.

Mo Brings Plenty and his brother, Joe Brings Plenty Sr., sat down with series creator Spencer Hudnut and the show’s writers to share their family’s grief and guide how the episode was told.

“We had an opportunity to share our experience, what was going on, where we’re at, and how we’re dealing with everything,” Mo Brings Plenty said of the collaboration. “They took it, and they created a beautiful storyline… After I read this particular script, my heart filled with gratitude. To be honest, not many folks would take this subject and bring it to light on the show. In the past, we talked about MMIW [Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women], MMIP [Missing and Murdered Indigenous People], and so on and so forth. However, it’s a different thing entirely to tell a story that highlights what’s really occurring throughout Indian country. I’m just very grateful.”

He described filming the episode as a cathartic but difficult experience, supported by castmates including Luke Grimes, Gil Birmingham, Will Strongheart and Tatanka Means.

“People knew what was going on with me and my family. Luke Grimes, Gil Birmingham, Will Strongheart, Tatanka Means, and the crew help tell this story so beautifully. It was a very vulnerable experience because we relived a lot of the heartbreaking moments. It felt good to have a group of amazing people by my side through it all. I also kept thinking about the other families throughout Indian Country who are going through the same thing and who have not had an opportunity to share their experience as I did. It felt like we were telling this story for them too.”

Mo Brings Plenty also said the production gave the cast and crew room to remember his nephew personally, recalling “the funny things that [Cole had] done,” along with “his kindness and his love and compassion for others.” He added that Cole “was always quick to help anyone in need; he was always there to give a hand up to someone. It didn’t matter what nationality they were or who they were. That was Cole.”

For Johnson County, the episode brings renewed outside attention to a case local officials closed as involving no foul play — a conclusion the family and tribal leaders continue to dispute.

Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

You May Also Like

Government Corruption

Updated 5/17/19 9:52am Jack Crane | Opinion  James Baker, Former-FBI General Counsel has joined Russian hoax media collaborator Michael Isikoff on his podcast, yesterday....

US Politics

I do not even know where to begin with this one.  Just when you think you have seen the worst that humanity has to...

US News

Education is considered to be one of the pillars of a successful life. Without a college degree, many believe these students will earn lower...

US News

ICYMI| If it were not for Tom Fitton and Judicial Watch, it is more than likely that the world would never know the extent...